Showing posts with label greeting cards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label greeting cards. Show all posts

Saturday, January 2, 2010

My Holiday Lesson? Some People Still Send Greeting Cards, but Not Necessarily the Ones I Bought for the Store

After Christmas, we marked down our Christmas cards 50%. We had a very nice sell-through on boxed. I overdid "cute" and could have sold more of "beautiful snow scene (painting or photo)" and "religious." I actually went back to one vendor late and brought in another two religious designs. Complete sell through before markdown.

We had a lot more loose cards left, partly because in the Schwartz transition, the cards that the Downer Schwartz had became nonreturnable (we were on racking programs). We put out 2 spinners of loose cards, plus about 3 columns in our regular card display, and still didn't get them all out. The card we had the most copies of was "It's my favorite time of year" (at right). The punch line is "Table scraps." We had over 24 of them. I'm really not sure how that happened.

On loose, we probably had too much religious. We also had cards for "wife", "husband", "brother" and "grandmother." I guess these sell in other markets (I once had a heated discussion at a gift show about whether a frame should say "sister" or whether you actually know it's your sister when you insert the photo), but not so much at the bookstore. We just don't have enough cards to be so specific. I'm not a fan of one line of cards, and it turns out, neither are too many of my customers. After two complete holiday seasons and two rounds of markdowns, we still have a lot left over, plus we're still sitting on some everyday from them. The more likely scenario is that there are perfectly nice cards in this line, but we're stuck with the dregs.

Most of our loose cards were inherited, but I did buy about 12 pockets new. Sadly, for two of the three lines I bought, I already figured out that their everyday lines did not move that quickly in the store, so you can imagine how excited I was when I remembered I had bought some holiday too.

My worst idea, a really cute card for late holiday givers (left). The problem? Who buys a "sorry about the late holiday card" early, which means you can only sell this marked down, or give a long-winded explanation about why this card does not qualify for the markdown? I'm tired just thinking about it, so I'm simply sending them out now myself. I don't even think about sending holiday cards (which I view more as a thank-you, as I sent about 75 out last year and got 7 back this year) until the 26th of December anyway.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

A Little Note on Greeting Cards Part 2--A Short Q&A with artist Andy Pratt

This is not the most efficient way to get cards, but in my quest for unique lines, I have found myself trawling the internet. Several times, I have adjusted the keywords on my search engine so that I could just browse different web sites.

It turns out that one line I wound up buying was carried by a sales rep I had already worked with. I didn't really sit down with her, however, so I consider it my fault. That said, I really like their cards a lot, as do several of my other booksellers (Amie?), being that one of their recurring characters is a sock monkey. Yes, get ready for a sock monkey display to appear in our store soon.

Another line that I discovered via e-labor was Andy Pratt, a New York based line that seems to be pretty much Mr. Pratt and some billing help. Pratt has a very sweet style that features a lot of city scenes, a bit of anthropomorphism (cupcakes wishing you happy birthday and pills offering get well greetings), plus a series of designs called "little struggle."

I figured the line was small enough that I could ask Andy Pratt how he got into it (particularly because I know half a dozen artists in Milwaukee who should have greeting card lines, unless they saw that as a massive sellout) and guess what? He said ok.

Welcome, Andy Pratt!

A: Thanks so much! I would be honored to answer some questions and tell you a little more about myself.

Q: How did you get into the business?

A: Several years ago I started the tradition of designing a holiday card for my freelance clients, friends and family. After a time my mother-in-law suggested I start the company, since I had enough for an initial line. I mixed in a couple thank you and birthday cards and Andy Pratt Design was born.

Q: What’s your inspiration?

A: Although my line is balanced with different styles and subjects, I discovered that I really like drawing dense urban scenes: things that might be backgrounds for someone else but became the main character for me. The Times Square Thank You card and I Miss You card are good examples of this. (Daniel's note: we carry both)

“My Location Series” takes this impulse and executes it in a more simple and sophisticated way through single color letterpress printing. All of the location drawings all have one rule: they are places I have been (including Austin). They tend to focus on the New York area, partially because I have a bit more access to it, and because there is a market for it here. I have several other sketches for location cards I would like to do, like Vancouver, Los Angeles, and Dubrovnik. Hopefully I'll get to those soon, but as I just had a baby in June that may take awhile!

(Daniel's note: we are not carrying these yet. I’ve had trouble moving our New York cards from another vendor. I grew up in New York myself, and almost swooned when I saw the Queens skyline, which was where my family lived. But not yet, alas. The market for most of location cards tends to be the location itself. Attention Milwaukee artists—we could use some Milwaukee drawings.)

Q: I am of the “interesting graphic, simple message school.” We mix in some quotes and witticisms because I know other folks like them (that’s why I have several different booksellers look through the card catalogs before I buy from them). What’s your philosophy on the greeting?

A: In general I like my cards to say a lot with a little. All of them are blank inside except for one: the text inside reads Fang You Very Much). I like to think the illustrations speak for themselves!

Hurray, another interview completed! Next up, Margaret Atwood. Just kidding. But visit our store to see the complete Andy Pratt line. Be prepared that we sort cards by type, not by line.

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

A Little Note on Greeting Cards, Part One

One of the things I decided to take on in the new job is buying cards, together with my bookseller Anne. Before I left Schwartz, our then buyer Catherine emphasized a sage piece of advice: "See if you can do it without a racker."

A racker is when the retailer contracts out to the card company to fill the racks. Hallmark likely racks the Walgreens in your neighborhood, Carlton Cards probably takes care of the Target, and Sunrise is most likely handling the Barnes and Noble that you frequent..."Just for that magazine you don't carry, Dan!"

Over the years, Schwartz used rackers for things like maps (not much of a business left there for us) and Cliff's Notes (and even less there). In other words, things you thought you could sell that you didn't care about messing with yourself. In both cases, I eventually cancelled the programs because we were oversaturated with product. If you're a big company, they may rack you on consignment, but not the small guy--you generally pay up front.

But it turns out that we like cards very much, and it's much more interesting to find cards you like. We're using about a dozen companies, leaving out the key lines that our friend Lynn at Paperwork carries (including some of the best lines like Caspari and Great Arrow). This gives us a very different selection.

I'm not giving much away here because you'd figure it out in a minute if you came to our store, but I'd say our core line is Madison Park. It's either because it's a pretty broad line and several of us like the cards a lot, they turn quickly, no one close to us carries them aggressively, or perhaps because several years ago I went to Seattle and my coworker Sarah's sister gave me a tour of their offices and warehouse. It was very fun and I feel connected somehow.
We find cards in lots of different ways. We have sales reps, just like for books. It's the easiest way to learn about product; the downside is that sometimes the lines will be in too many nearby shops. I picked up a few lines at the Chicago gift show from a rep that has the Milwaukee territory but doesnn't make it up here much. When I travel, I look for interesting lines, buy a card, and try to bring it in for our store.

I thought the card was dead; I have sent my share of ecards myself. I'm finding that like many other things, it's an age thing. Then there are certain types of cards ("sympathy" for sure, also "thank you") where an ecard doesn't show enough effort. The birch tree card at left has proven to be quite popular as a sympathy card--something different from the flower and the sunset, I guess. And finally, when you're buying a gift, it makes sense to have the card with it, as opposed to coming separately via email. And finally, if you subscribe to an email service, you run out of good options pretty quickly.

So card sales turn out to be tracking okay, not quite what we were doing before percentagewise, but hardly plummetting. We're getting our fair share of compliments and nary a complaint. For some reason, a few of us get a real thrill when someone comes up with a pile of them to buy.

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Sitting Here at the Kitchen Table, Reordering Cards

When we opened the store, I had dreams of tracking two kinds of SKU's that we didn't scan at Schwartz.

The first was magazines, which we have done successfully. For some reason, we're not tracking newspapers, but we really don't sell that many.

The only problem with magazines is that I have at least one bookseller who occasionally rings through purchases in the old way. It is throwing off our inventory and it has to be fixed. Unfortunately, none of my staff seems to think they are doing it. I'll have to play detective, and I'll let you know if I ever figure out the answer.

The second was cards, and on that idea, I was overruled. You'd think the owner would get free reign on this kind of thing, but alas not.

We decided to not go with a racker, which Schwartz did generally. It's more work this way, but you can control the cards better in terms of quality (less clunkers) and quantity (the inventory is substantially lower). On the other hand, with the rack program, you generally get returnability. But you have to commit to a lot of space, and honestly, we have a nice-sized-but-not-huge card section that we don't want to tie up with one vendor. We took the advice of Schwartz gift buyer Catherine and went rackerless and it's working ok so far. Thanks, Catherine!

So we reorder using backers (that thing that says, "You've just sold out of card #123. Please reorder!" I don't know if this is actually what you call them, by the way.) This works well, but since some card companies provide backers, and other don't, we often have to make our own. And if someone puts a card back in the wrong place, we might reorder a card we still have. The photo attached is of a bunch of Madison Park backers, which I am reordering at home on a spread sheet.

The biggest problem is finding cards for certain occasions, especially the way we laid our the four areas. We're short on "new home" for example. We've chosen to avoid relative-specific cards (son, grandma), some of which we're still sitting on from Schwartz (remember, we bought the inventory). And we don't know what occasions our customers are looking for that they can't find. Someday I'll have that suggestion box!

Sometimes we run out of envelopes but still have cards leftover. This is sometimes from a customer taking a different envelope than the one that goes with the card (I'm just letting you know folks, that when you do this, we wind up with cards and envelopes that don't match). But the really icky thing that I'm told happens (I'm new to this) is that people sometimes steal envelopes for their homemade cards.

Ewwww. Stealing my envelopes is still stealing. You should be ashamed.

And just a reminder, Paperwork across the street sells envelopes in lots of different colors. Hold your head high and buy your envelopes across the street. You'll feel better about yourself.